Ask Rick: Ridgid R4430 Planer Vs. DeWalt DW734 Planer | Tools Rule! | Toologics.com

Home

Resources

Ask Rick

Power Tools

Ask Rick: Ridgid R4430 Planer Vs. DeWalt DW734 Planer

Jan 03 2008

Ask Rick: Ridgid R4430 Planer Vs. DeWalt DW734 Planer

Written by Rick Peil

Thursday, 03 January 2008

I've been researching the Rigid R4430 - head planer. Is it as good as they say, there seems to be quite a bit of talk about it. It seems like it's aimed at Home Depot-are they only carrier of it? Do you think it's better than the DeWalt DW734? - Dave

Dave,

Happy New Year and thanks for the inquiry!

The Rigid R4430 is a nice portable planer with some nice features. I have used/demonstrated several portable planers, including the Ridgid. During the demonstration process I discovered, along with my customers, the Delta 13”, 2-Speed planer (22-580) produced the smoothest finish of all of them-even smoother than it’s DeWalt 13”, 3-knife (DW735) counterpart. By the way, the DeWalt DW734 is a 12½" planer and the DeWalt DW735 is slightly larger at 13", so the DW735 a better model to compare to the Ridgid R4430.

Having stated that, I also had a few customers who thought the 3-knife was slightly smoother. It would just seem to make sense the more knives in the planer, the smoother the cut. As my tests/demonstrations proved to me and my customers, this is not necessarily the case.

In the portable planer category the Rigid R4430 is a great value as are the Delta, DeWalt, Makita and Steel City planers and I would consider the DeWalt DW734 very comparable to the Rigid R4430.

Home Depot is the only distributor of Ridgid brand power tools, so the Rigid R4430 planer is exclusively sold at The Home Depot and nowhere else. However, Ridgid brand plumbing tools are sold at many stores that sell tools.

The one thing you might also want to consider is the serviceability of whatever you choose to purchase. After all, if your planer should require service, it would be nice to get it. In my opinion the Delta, DeWalt, Makita and Steel City portable planers offer a larger and more accessible service network.

Finally and if possible, I would recommend you take a small piece of wood to the Home Depot or any other tool distributor and put the planer(s) to the test. I find these tests very enlightening and you can really let the results speak for themselves.

By the way, I personally own the Delta 22-580 planer and it has run flawlessly for a long time. It's one of my favorite planers and I always recommend it to customers looking for a great 13" planer.

Good Luck and if you have any questions about planers (or any other tools for that matter), please feel free to give me a call directly at 1-800-696-TOOL, X202.

Happy Planning!

Got a question for our tool expert Rick Peil? Click here to ask Rick!

Related news items:

06/09/2009 - Ask Rick: What's a Good Jointer for Under $800?
06/01/2009 - Ask Rick: How Good is Dust Collection on SawStop Saws?
04/13/2009 - Ask Rick: Is Campbell Hausfeld a Good Brand and Will My Compressor Handle a Framing Nailer?
03/17/2009 - Ask Rick: Why Won't My DeWalt 734 Planer Pull Lumber Through?
03/05/2009 - Ask Rick: What's a Good SDS Max Rotary Hammer?
02/16/2009 - Ask Rick: How Do I Replace the Drive Belt on a DeWalt 735 Planer?
02/13/2009 - Jointer WITH A 46" TABLE AND PUT A STRAIGHT EDGE ON A PIECE OF 3/4 LUMBER ? I MAKE CABINET DOORS AND IT IS HARD TO GET THE L…</div>', 270);" onmouseout="hidettip();">Ask Rick: Can I Use a Jointer to Get a Straight Edge on a Piece of Lumber?
02/12/2009 - Ask Rick: What's the Best Jig Saw to Cut Plywood?
02/05/2009 - Ask Rick: What's the Advantage of Reduced Vibration/Shock in Air Tools?
02/04/2009 - Ask Rick: Type of Grease to Use in a Gear Housing

Newer news items:

11/25/2008 - Ask Rick: Help Me Fix My DeWalt 735 Planer!
09/08/2008 - Ask Rick: What's the Best Way to Manage Community Woodshop Equipment?
09/04/2008 - table saw. I am looking at the Sawstop Contractor saw for the obvious safety reasons along with their…</div>', 270);" onmouseout="hidettip();">Ask Rick: How Does the SawStop Contractor Saw Compare to Other Saws?
07/03/2008 - Ask Rick: How Do You Feel About the Quality of the SawStop Contractor Saw?
04/01/2008 - Ask Rick: When Are New Makita Li-Ion Tools Coming?
03/31/2008 - Ask Rick: How Do I Make My Belt Sander Collect Dust?
03/26/2008 - Ask Rick: How Does a DeWalt Cordless Brad Nailer Work?
03/24/2008 - Ask Rick: What are SDS MAX and SDS TOOLBAR?
03/05/2008 - Ask Rick: Which Jointer? Steel City 40615g or Powermatic 54A?
02/26/2008 - Ask Rick: Buying a Table Saw

Older news items:

12/12/2007 - Are Contractor Table Saws Good Enough for an Accomplished Cabinetmaker?
09/19/2007 - SawStop: Safety Features Aside, How Is It as a Saw?
09/12/2007 - Multi-Use Power Tools: Fein Multi-Master
09/06/2007 - Pocket hole or domino. They all join wood but when should I use one over the other? - Andy Andy, …</div>', 270);" onmouseout="hidettip();">When to use a dovetail, pocket hole or domino joint
08/30/2007 - Using a Belt Sander to Repair Warped Boards

<< Previous pageNext Page >>

Set as favorite

Bookmark

Email This

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (6) add comment

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Colin said:

The Ridgid power tools, including the planers, are not real Ridgid. The real Ridgid tools are the pipe threaders, pipe benders, etc.

My company is an authorized Ridgid distributor, but we cannot sell the drills, etc, even if we wanted to. Ridgid licenses the right to other manufacturers for their name. You cannot buy any parts from Ridgid. They make you run all over the place, and the parts are almost impossible to get, and they're expensive.

Makita, DeWalt and Milwaukee are the top three tools, and they all hold parts for tools for many, many years.

So, the Ridgid may be cheap and nice in the short-run, but in the long run, they are just going to scrapped.

report abuse

vote down

vote up

January 11, 2008
Votes: -1

jude said:

	Thanks for the great info. I didn't know that was the case with Ridgid tools. Perhaps Home Depot has an exclusive license for the Ridgid power tool line and that could be why no one else can sell them and you can't find parts anywhere.
	report abuse vote down vote up

January 14, 2008
Votes: +0

Matt Worner said:

I am lead to believe, and I can't remember where I heard, that Home Depot owns Ridge Tool Co. Is that not the case? Rigid pipe cutting and threading equipment has been the industry standard since I was an apprentice (electrician) 40 odd years ago but their introduction into the consumer power tool market is fairly recent. As for liscensing, nobody in the US makes anything any more, all tools are made offshore and custom branded. We haven't developed any new industry to talk of in this country for year. Design it here and run to China to have it built. DUMB!

report abuse

vote down

vote up

January 22, 2008
Votes: +0

jude said:

	Yup, you're right. The good thing is that they can't outsource contractor jobs to China.
	report abuse vote down vote up

January 22, 2008
Votes: +0

Tedd said:

	As a Manager for Home Depot I will dispell the myth.. We Do Not Own Ridgid... a company by the name of TTI (Techtronics Industry) or One World Tech owns and manufactures Ridgid, Ryobi, Milwaukee, and Hoover vacuums. When I first started at Depot 8 years ago I also thought that we owned them. I wish we did though!
	report abuse vote down vote up

March 13, 2008
Votes: +0

Ben said:

	Some Makita tools, notably the miter saws, are still assembled in the good ol' USA. As for almost everything else, it's all China or Mexico.
	report abuse vote down vote up